windowsill lab · preprint draft

A blind transit search with a closed disposition vocabulary

116 threshold crossings, nine recoveries, seven leads, six of them refuted, no discovery. Published here as a working draft before journal submission; every number re-derives from committed receipts and dated rulings.

The refuted lead: TIC 374861595 → The method as a kit →

Depth 0 · no science needed

A reader’s guide

The paper below is written for astronomers and stays exactly as drafted. This guide sits in front of it. Already in the field? Skip to the contents.

In one breath. Two home computers searched public NASA telescope data for stars that dim on a schedule, the sign of something orbiting them. This paper is not about a discovery. It is about a search built so that anyone can check every answer it gave, including the ones it threw away. Its machines are not allowed to say “planet”: every signal gets one label from a fixed list of 18, and the furthest any machine can go is “a person should look at this”.

The numbers, as a story

  1. 12,898 searches

    One search is one star’s brightness record, checked for repeating dips. Seven month-long patches of sky.

  2. 116 crossed the bar

    Only these stood out enough to look at. Each got a label from the fixed list, most of them ordinary explanations like two stars eclipsing each other.

  3. 9 known planets found without a hint

    A test that the search works: it was not told where they were, and found them anyway.

  4. 0 hits from 1,850 fakes

    A test that it does not invent things: scrambled records with no real dips in them produced nothing.

  5. 7 leads, 5 killed by its own checks

    Of the seven signals that survived to the end, the lab’s own later checks threw out five. One is parked waiting on missing data.

  6. 1 refuted after an astronomer wrote in

    TIC 374861595 stood as the open lead for ten weeks, until an astronomer explained why it is most likely two stars, not a planet. The lab’s own data bore that out, and the part of the paper that used it as a worked example is withdrawn.

Read it in this order

  1. The dated note at the top of the draft: what the 2026-11-10 refutation withdraws.
  2. The abstract: the whole paper in one paragraph.
  3. The plain-language page for TIC 374861595, then §6, the worked example, which is now withdrawn.
  4. §5, the refutation record: how the search killed its own best leads.
  5. §4, calibration: the known-planet and fake-data tests.
  6. Then the rest. §2 and the appendices are the machinery.
Words in the paper, in plain language
Transit, light curve
A transit is the dip when something passes in front of a star. A light curve is a star’s brightness over time.
TESS, sector, TIC
NASA’s sky-survey satellite, the month-long patches it watches, and its numbered catalogue of stars.
BLS, SDE, threshold crossing
Box Least Squares slides a box-shaped dip along the data at every trial period. SDE scores how far the best peak stands out. A threshold crossing is a star whose score clears the bar (SDE 8.0).
Disposition, closed vocabulary
A disposition is the label a signal ends up with. Closed means the list of allowed labels is fixed in code, and none of them is “planet”.
Recovery
Finding a planet that was already known, without being told it was there. It shows the search can see.
Placebo, phase-scrambled
A real light curve shuffled so any real dips are destroyed. A search that “finds” something in one is fooling itself.
Injection
Planting a fake dip of known size into real data to measure how small a dip the search can still catch on that star.
Lead, refutation
A lead is a signal that passed every automatic check and waits for a person. A refutation is a lead later ruled out, by the lab’s own checks or after an outside review.
Eclipsing binary, harmonic alias
Two stars taking turns blocking each other; and a search locking onto half or double the true period. The two commonest false alarms.
SPOC, TOI, CTOI, ExoFOP
NASA’s automatic pipeline; its official follow-up list; a candidate proposed from outside; the website that holds both.
Receipt
A results file committed to the public repository, so every number can be re-derived by anyone.
PASP, AJ
Two peer-reviewed astronomy journals, the targets for this draft.

Depth 1 · the paper itself

From here on, the draft as written.

Draft, 2026-09-18. Not submitted. Nothing in this paper has been sent anywhere.

Overtaken on 2026-11-10, and not yet rewritten. The worked example, TIC 374861595, was refuted, on outside review and then on the lab's own 24 sectors, as most likely an eclipsing binary at twice the period (docs/investigations/2026-11-10-tic374861595-eb-at-2p-refutation.md). Withdrawn: the abstract's claim that the object "remains open", §1's paragraph on the worked example, §5's "one is open", all of §6, and the parts of §8 that rest on that star's secondary-eclipse bound. §5's "Seven refutation rulings" is now eight, six of them counted. Only the census table in §3 has been updated for the ruling. The title's "five refutations" counts the survey's own gates; the sixth began with a TOI vetter. If this paper goes ahead, the star is its worked refuted lead.

Target venue: PASP or AJ — a peer-reviewed journal, chosen for that property and not for speed. The venue reasoning is in docs/submissions/TIC374861595-CTOI.md §3; the short form is that Research Notes of the AAS is described by the AAS itself as non-peer-reviewed, which disqualifies it both as a referee and as the credential ExoFOP's community-candidate policy now requires.

This draft supersedes docs/submissions/TIC374861595-paper-outline.md, which planned the same paper and is the source of §6's structure and §7's blocker list. It is not a replacement for the CTOI package: TIC374861595-CTOI.md remains the package of record for the object, and this document cites it rather than restating it. Both, and the two scripts §6–7 name, land with PR #163; this draft is written on top of that branch and its file references resolve there.

Every census number below is re-derived from the committed receipts in reports/hunts/ by scripts/survey_paper_numbers.py, which reads and computes nothing else, and which asserts its agreement with the aggregator that writes pot.json. tests/test_survey_paper_numbers.py checks this document's census table against that reader, cell by cell.


Abstract

We describe a small archival transit search built to be checkable rather than productive, and report the full disposition record of its first 12,898 target-searches over seven TESS sectors. Every one of the 116 detections above the SDE = 8.0 threshold carries a machine disposition drawn from a closed 18-term vocabulary that contains no word for "planet"; the terminal machine state is lead-awaiting-human-review. The search recovers nine known transiting planets that were not designated in advance, returns zero candidates from 1,850 phase-scrambled placebo light curves, measures a per-host injection depth limit for 1,565 hosts and bars 384 of them from aggregate sensitivity statements on their own measured blindness, and refuses five of its own hunt receipts outright when their controls fail. Of seven leads the pipeline minted, five were subsequently killed by the survey's own gates, one is parked on a named gap, and one — TIC 374861595, an uncatalogued 10.5 % signal on a mid-M dwarf that the SPOC pipeline has detected 259 times without promotion to TOI — remains open. We present that object as a worked example rather than as a result: the survey's contribution to it is an independent blind recovery inside a sample with a denominator, and a sharper use of one measurement the standard promotion path already makes: a surface-brightness bound from the absent secondary eclipse that is independent of the grazing degeneracy. A limb-darkened refit over 24 sectors and 5.3 years, with a host radius derived from 2MASS photometry and a Gaia DR3 parallax rather than adopted from a catalogue, leaves the companion's radius less constrained than the catalogue pipeline did — the fitted geometry is grazing to the point of being marginally non-transiting — and leaves a 7.7 σ disagreement between the stellar density implied by the transit shape and the density of the host. We report both rather than resolve them. We claim no planet. A pre-registered census of the public SPOC catalogue finds the object's signature — high MES, grazing, R_p > 2 R_Jup, faint M dwarf — on 130 stars, 125 of them never promoted to TOI, and shows that the secondary-eclipse bound is only safe paired with an odd/even test: unpaired it "excludes" a stellar companion on 63 of them, paired on 20. We argue that the useful publishable content of a small survey is its disposition record and its refusals, and that both are cheap to produce and almost never reported.


1 · Introduction

Small archival transit searches are easy to run and hard to believe. The search itself is a solved problem — box least squares over detrended photometry is thirty years old and a few hundred lines — and the archive is open, so the barrier to producing a list of candidates from TESS data is close to zero. The barrier to producing a list anyone should act on is not.

The gap between those two is almost entirely bookkeeping, and bookkeeping is what small surveys do not publish. A search that reports its survivors and not its denominator cannot be distinguished from a search that reports whatever survived a threshold chosen after looking. A search that reports "candidates" without saying what the other detections were, and why, has published the tail of a distribution whose body it is asking the reader to imagine. A search with no negative control has not shown that its pipeline would decline to produce candidates from data containing none.

This paper reports a survey built the other way round. The instrument was designed so that its record — not its results — would be the thing worth publishing, on the grounds that a small survey's realistic yield is zero discoveries and that a zero-discovery survey is publishable exactly to the extent that its zero is a measurement rather than an absence of effort.

Three design decisions carry that:

  1. A closed disposition vocabulary. Every detection above threshold gets a machine verdict drawn from a fixed 18-term list (§2.4). The list contains no word for "planet" and no word for "discovery". A detection cannot leave the pipeline undispositioned, and the most a machine path can say about the best thing it ever found is lead-awaiting-human-review.
  2. A per-target null, and controls on the controls. Each graded detection carries an empirical false-alarm probability from permutations of its own light curve (§2.2), each run carries a pre-data uniformity control on those FAPs, and each run carries a whole-pipeline placebo (§4).
  3. Refusal rather than repair. A receipt whose own controls fail is refused at aggregation time and named in the published record, not fixed and not silently dropped (§3.3). Five of eighty committed receipts are in that state.

The survey has found no planets, and §5 reports in detail the five leads it minted and then killed. We take the refutation record to be the paper's substance. A pipeline whose gates never take anything away is indistinguishable, from outside, from a pipeline whose gates are not wired — and §4.4 describes the three weeks in 2026 when ours was exactly that, and how we found out.

§6 works one object end to end. TIC 374861595 is not a discovery: SPOC found the signal first, in 2020, and has redetected it in every 2-minute sector the target has been observed in since. What the survey adds is a blind recovery inside a sample whose size is known, and one measurement — a companion bound from the absent secondary eclipse that survives the grazing degeneracy — drawn from a depth the promotion path already computes but does not turn into this bound, and available in the same archive the whole time. We present it as the survey's worked example because a methods paper whose method never meets a hard case has not been tested.


2 · The instrument

Targets are drawn from the 2-minute SPOC light curves of a single sector at a time, ranked by a consistent hash of the TIC identifier under a fixed seed (2026), with graded-run and prior-hunt targets excluded. The ranking is declared in each receipt's slice_rule field and is a pure function of the identifier, so a slice is reproducible from the seed alone and cannot be reordered after seeing an outcome.

Detrending and the periodogram follow lab.a04.blind_search: a frequency-uniform grid of 3,000 trial periods, box least squares at each, and a detection statistic SDE = (max − median)/std computed over that periodogram. The threshold is SDE ≥ 8.0, fixed across every receipt in this sample (§2.3 states what that threshold is and is not calibrated against).

2.2 The per-target null

The statistic being calibrated is not box power at the detected period. It is the maximum over the whole period grid, because that maximum is what a blind search reports, and a null that re-tests only the detected period would ignore the look-elsewhere effect across 3,000 trials and understate the false-alarm probability substantially.

Each Stage-2 target therefore gets B = 256 permutations of its own detrended flux, each of which is re-searched over the same grid and reduced to its own SDE by the same convention. Two permutation schemes are run:

Both are stored in the receipt. The graded FAP is the more conservative of the two, as the empirical bound p = (1 + k)/(B + 1) where k counts null maxima at or above the observed SDE. A Gumbel tail fit is also recorded and is explicitly reported-never-graded; a failed bulk calibration nulls that block rather than downgrading it.

Two limits of this construction are declared rather than discovered by a referee:

2.3 What the threshold is priced against

Five receipts in this sample consulted a pooled scramble null of 325,000 draws whose maximum SDE is 8.65 — above the 8.0 threshold. The receipts record that fact in a field named for it (threshold_below_null_max: true) rather than leaving it to be noticed. Thirteen of those 325,000 draws exceeded the threshold, giving a per-target false-alarm probability at threshold of ≤ 6.4 × 10⁻⁵ at 95 % confidence, and therefore an expectation of roughly 0.8 false crossings across the 12,898 searches in this sample, if that null describes the whole sample — which it was not measured over.

So the threshold does not sit above the noise. It sits where a per-target graded FAP and a disposition are required to interpret anything that crosses it, which is the design. A reader should expect of order one of the 116 crossings in §3 to be noise, and should not expect the survey to be able to say which.

The remaining 70 accepted receipts predate the pooled null and record null in that field. They are not retrofitted.

2.4 The disposition vocabulary

The vocabulary is a single module (lab.a05_vocab) read by both the engine that writes dispositions and the checker that grades receipts, deliberately stdlib-only so the checker can import it without importing the engine whose output it is checking. It defines 18 terms, walked in ladder order: series gates (pulsation, harmonic alias, odd/even depth, secondary eclipse, P/2 alias, phased brightening, low significance, insufficient coverage, period rail, centroid shift, companion too large), then sky gates (blended known planet, blend favours neighbour), then catalogue identification (recovery-or-known, known-planet, TOI-known-FP, CTOI-known), then the terminal human-review state.

It contains no term planet. A receipt whose machine emitted one is refused outright at aggregation, and planets_discovered in the published ledger is a pinned literal zero that no code path can raise: promotion is a human act recorded in MILESTONES.md, not a value computed from JSON.

That the vocabulary is one object with two readers is not a stylistic preference. For two days in August 2026 it was two literals, the engine learned five new honest words from the sky gates, and the checker kept the old thirteen — so the first genuine refutation those gates produced would have failed the checker's vocabulary gate and quarantined the entire receipt, losing the slice and silently returning its targets to the eligible pool. The merge was a bug fix, and the bug was that a restated contract is not a contract.

2.5 The receipt

One run produces one JSON receipt in reports/hunts/, carrying every row it attempted with its outcome, the SHA-256 of the cached FITS bytes it read, the full permutation maxima for both schemes, the injection ladder and measured depth limit of every Stage-2 host, the run's controls, and a claim_boundary string that the publication path ships verbatim. The aggregator re-derives every counter from those rows and never reads a receipt's own counts block (rule 2 of the schema): a receipt that misreports its own totals is caught rather than repeated.


3 · The census

Table 1 — the survey record. Every row is re-derived from the committed receipts by scripts/survey_paper_numbers.py. As of the newest accepted receipt, 2026-09-13.

quantity value note
target-searches 12,898 sum over receipts of work done; not a count of stars
distinct identities 12,151 distinct TICs appearing in searched rows
pilot stars counted by a floor 551 schema-0 pilot; identities not individually recorded
rows attempted 13,524
rows with no usable product 1,094
rows that errored 83
receipts accepted 75
receipts refused 5 refused by their own controls; §3.3
receipts superseded 1 extended by a later run; excluded to avoid double-counting
above threshold 116 distinct stars, SDE ≥ 8.0, newest verdict
dispositioned 116 / 116 from the closed 18-term vocabulary; 14 terms used
Stage-2 rows 1,758 targets that paid for a per-target null
injections run 31,644
injections recovered 20,538 64.9 %
ladder hosts 1,565 hosts with a measured per-period depth limit
hosts barred as insensitive 384 could not recover a 1 % transit at any ladder period
placebo scrambles 1,850
placebo candidates 0
known planets recovered 9 none designated in advance
leads minted 7
leads refuted 6 five by the survey's own gates (§5); TIC 374861595 on outside review, 2026-11-10
leads parked 1 on a named gap
leads awaiting review 0 TIC 374861595 was the one; refuted 2026-11-10
planets claimed 0 pinned literal

3.1 The denominator, stated precisely

12,898 is a count of target-searches, not of stars. The aggregator sums it per receipt on purpose — re-searching a star in a later slice really is more work — but a survey's denominator is stars, and the two differ here. Of the 12,347 searched rows carrying identities, 12,151 are distinct; the remaining 551 belong to a pre-A05 pilot receipt that recorded a noise floor over its sample rather than a row per star, so those identities are not individually recoverable and may overlap the 12,151.

The honest statement is therefore: 12,898 target-searches over at least 12,151 and at most 12,702 distinct stars, across TESS sectors 2, 3, 30, 31, 35, 42 and 96. We use the search count where the quantity is work and the identity count where the quantity is sky, and we do not average the two.

3.2 The dispositions

Table 2 — every threshold crossing, by verdict. 116 of 116; the four vocabulary terms not appearing here (eclipsing-binary-p2-alias, period-railed, blended-known-planet, blend-favours-neighbour) are defined and were not the newest verdict on any star in this sample.

disposition n
eclipsing-binary-odd-even 20
low-significance 17
eclipsing-binary-secondary 16
harmonic-alias 16
stellar-pulsation 14
recovery-or-known 10
lead-awaiting-human-review 7
toi-known-fp 3
known-planet 3
insufficient-coverage 3
centroid-shift 3
phased-brightening 2
ctoi-known 1
companion-too-large 1

Eclipsing binaries in their two obvious presentations account for 36 of 116. Harmonic aliases account for another 16 — the classical failure mode of a box search, and the one that produced this survey's most instructive refutation (§5.2).

Three crossings are toi-known-fp: the community had already refuted the signal as a false positive or false alarm, so the row is neither a recovery nor a lead. Counting them as recoveries would inflate the recovery statistic with things nobody recovered.

3.3 The refused receipts

Five receipts are excluded from every counter in Table 1 and named in the published record with their reason:

receipt refused because
hunt-2026-08-14-s3.json uniformity control failed
hunt-2026-08-16-s2.json over its declared compute budget share
hunt-2026-08-17-s2-0026.json uniformity control failed
hunt-2026-08-17-s2.json over its declared compute budget share
hunt-2026-08-18-s2-1000.json uniformity control failed

Refusal is at aggregation, by the same checker that grades receipts, and it is not discretionary: a receipt the checker will not grade is not a receipt the ledger may count. One of the five was the sole source of a lead, which left the ledger with it (§5.4).

This gate was added in September 2026 after an audit found the aggregator counting receipts whose own uniformity control had failed — the checker returned "every graded FAP here is uninterpretable" and the aggregator counted the run anyway. The five refusals above are that audit's finding, published rather than repaired.


4 · Calibration

4.1 What the search recovers

Nine known transiting planets were recovered blind. None was designated in advance; each was identified at grading time by catalogue cross-match after the search had already reported its period.

Table 3 — blind recoveries.

planet TIC sector SDE recovered P (d) published P (d) ΔP/P
HIP 65 A b 201248411 2 14.22 0.9812412 0.980972 +2.7 × 10⁻⁴
WASP-45 b 120610833 2 11.15 3.1248448 3.1260751 −3.9 × 10⁻⁴
WASP-96 b 160148385 2 10.02 3.4287693 3.4252563 +1.0 × 10⁻³
HATS-34 b 355703913 2 11.29 2.1048482 — —
TOI-125 b 52368076 2 8.31 4.6567334 — —
WASP-119 b 388104525 3 8.14 2.5000709 2.4997996 +1.1 × 10⁻⁴
WASP-18 b 100100827 30 10.21 0.9416280 0.9414525 +1.9 × 10⁻⁴
WASP-53 b 268766053 30 9.70 3.3085095 3.3098458 −4.0 × 10⁻⁴
WASP-190 b 116156517 96 8.15 5.3748547 5.36777 +1.3 × 10⁻³

Periods agree with the published values to between 1.1 × 10⁻⁴ and 1.3 × 10⁻³ fractionally, consistent with a single-sector baseline of ~27 days. Three rows carry no published period in the receipt; their identification rests on the catalogue match alone and the comparison is not made here rather than made against a number the receipt does not hold.

Nine recoveries is a weak statement about completeness and we do not strengthen it. The survey does not report an occurrence rate, a detection efficiency curve, or a completeness fraction, because the sample was selected by a hash rather than by any astrophysical criterion and because 384 of its 1,565 measured hosts are barred as insensitive (§4.3). What the recoveries establish is that the pipeline end to end — detrend, search, grade, disposition — returns real transiting planets from real archival data without being told where to look.

One recovery is a boundary case worth stating. WASP-18 b has a genuine 399 ppm secondary eclipse, so the series gate that kills eclipsing binaries on their secondaries fires on it correctly. The schema resolves this by letting catalogue identity outrank a bare secondary verdict only for confirmed planets (TFOPWG KP/CP), preserving the physics verdict in disposition_evidence.initial_verdict rather than erasing it. For anything not already confirmed, the physics verdict stands. This is the one place the pipeline consults an oracle, it is bounded to confirmed objects, and it is recorded on the row.

4.2 What the search refuses to find

1,850 phase-scrambled light curves — same flux values, same cadence times, same gaps, same noise distribution, zero phase coherence — were run through the full search and vetting ladder, not merely the ranker. They produced zero candidates.

This is the negative control the survey leans on hardest, because it is the one that tests the part a periodogram null does not: a permutation FAP calibrates the statistic, while the placebo asks whether the ladder behind the statistic will manufacture a candidate from a curve that contains none. One would be too many.

4.3 Per-host sensitivity, and hosts that are allowed to say nothing

A survey-wide positive control answers the wrong question. The predecessor pipeline injected three boxes into one host and demanded all three back, so a single host with unlucky photometry missing one injection declared a healthy run failed.

This survey asks instead how deep can this host see. Every Stage-2 host gets a predeclared ladder — depths 0.2 %, 0.4 %, 1.0 % × periods 2.3, 3.7, 5.1 d × two epochs, chosen before any hunt ran and never retuned — and a missed 0.2 % injection is not a failure but the measurement: it degrades that host's depth limit d_min and weakens the null statement the survey may make about it.

31,644 injections were run and 20,538 recovered. 1,565 hosts carry a measured depth limit; the median limit is 0.2 % at all three ladder periods, which is the ladder's own floor rung, so the true limit for a typical host is somewhere below 0.2 % and this ladder cannot say where.

384 of the 1,565 hosts — 24.5 % — cannot recover a 1 % injection at any ladder period and are barred from aggregate sensitivity statements entirely. A survey that averaged those hosts in would be reporting a sensitivity its photometry never had on a quarter of its sample.

4.4 The calibration of the calibrator, and the gate that was not wired

Each run routes a fixed fraction of its targets to a uniformity control, chosen by a deterministic hash of (seed, TIC) with no SDE filter, so a control member may legitimately host a real astrophysical signal and drag the KS statistic. Filtering controls by outcome would bias the very calibration the control exists to test; a KS statistic degraded by a real signal is investigated, not excluded. Across 74 accepted receipts, 1,287 control members were graded, with a maximum KS statistic of 0.343.

Absence of a verdict is not a passed gate, and the survey learned this the expensive way. From 2026-08-20 the production hunt script called the engine without a neighbour resolver, so the sky gates — the ones that ask whose light this is, rather than what shape it has — were a silent no-op in the one place production leads are minted. A receipt with no sky verdict on any row was ambiguous between "ran and cleared everything" and "never ran", and for that period it meant the second. The repair is a sky_gates block that states the answer either way, including whether a resolver was supplied at all, so that "an unrun gate is not a passed gate" became a machine-checkable claim instead of a hope. A nonzero lookup_errors count means some lead could not be asked the question, and a run in that state is not permitted to become a receipt.

We report this because a reader has no way to distinguish a survey whose gates are wired from one whose gates are not, and because the class of defect — a control that is absent rather than failing — is the one least likely to be caught by any test that only checks outputs.


5 · The refutation record

Seven leads were minted. Five were refuted by the survey's own gates, one is parked, one is open. Seven refutation rulings are on the record; two of them belong to stars that are no longer minted leads, for reasons §5.4 gives, and are therefore not among the five.

All seven leads sit at the graded-FAP floor of 3.9 × 10⁻³ (§2.2), so none of what follows was decided by the statistic.

One point of attribution, because "the survey's own gates" could be read too generously. These refutations were not produced by the in-line vetting ladder that dispositions a row at hunt time — had they been, the stars would never have reached lead-awaiting-human-review at all. They come from a post-hoc sweep (2026-08-19/20) that re-ran the fold, catalogue and sky gates over every standing lead across every sector the star was observed in, and from a second look in a later sector. The verdicts are machine verdicts; the decision to run the sweep, and the transcription of each ruling into the rulings file, is human. The machine dispositions on those rows remain lead-awaiting-human-review, which is why the refutation count lives in a separate ledger rather than in the disposition table, and why §5.4's arithmetic exists at all.

5.1 Refuted on the fold, across sectors rather than within one

Four leads died on the same gate: fold the candidate at 2 P and compare odd with even eclipse depths, combined across every sector the star was observed in rather than within the sector that produced the detection.

TIC combined significance sectors also
234518605 28.3 σ 6 direct-period CTOI match
272357134 16.4 σ 8 two CTOIs at a direct period match
369603748 8.2 σ 2 —
49558810 8.6 σ 2 —

TIC 369603748 is the instructive one: its per-sector significances are 5.1 σ and 6.5 σ, and neither would have closed it. 8.2 σ combined did. Grading the star rather than the sector is what refuted it, and a survey that grades sectors independently would still be carrying this lead.

5.2 Refuted on physical admissibility

TIC 287328866 reached 9.8 σ combined over eight sectors as an eclipsing binary at a P/2 alias, and independently matched two CTOIs at alias n = 2. It is also the survey's physical-admissibility exemplar: the implied companion radius at the detected period is 2.5 R_Jup on an F subgiant, which is not a planet, not a brown dwarf and not a small star. A signal that implies an object no one has ever observed is evidence about the model, not about the object — and the vocabulary has a term for it (companion-too-large, carried by one other crossing in Table 2) so that the judgement is recorded as a verdict rather than made in prose.

5.3 Refuted as a real planet on a different star

TIC 77044472 is the best case in the record and it is not one of the five.

The light curve was never wrong; the pipeline never asked whose light it was. The dip is HATS-16 b — TOI 228.01, TFOPWG-dispositioned a known planet — on neighbour TIC 77044471, 0.71 pixels away, at a direct period match. This is a refutation of the target, not of the signal: a real transiting planet, correctly detected, attributed to the wrong star.

It is the case that produced the sky gates described in §4.4, and therefore the case that produced the discovery that those gates had not been running. A survey that reported this lead as a candidate would have been reporting a fifteen-year-old published planet as new, which is the specific failure that blended-known-planet and blend-favours-neighbour now exist to catch.

5.4 Two rulings that do not count, and why

Two refutation rulings do not reduce the lead count, because a ruling counts only while its star is a currently-minted lead:

We report the arithmetic because the alternative — publishing "seven leads, seven refutations" — would be adding two numbers that describe different things. The record carries both, and the aggregator's rule (a ruling counts against a minted lead, and the count never goes negative) is in lab.publish.hunt_block.

Until September 2026 this arithmetic was wrong in the other direction: the published ledger read the receipts alone and reported nine leads awaiting human review for three weeks after six of the nine had been ruled refuted, because refutations are written by a person into a rulings file and nothing ever wrote them back into the receipts. The arithmetic was correct throughout; the inputs were half the record.

5.5 The parked lead

TIC 212950885 (sector 42, SDE 9.82) is parked on a named gap rather than refuted or promoted. Parking is a distinct state precisely so that "we have not finished asking" cannot be silently recorded as either "refuted" or "awaiting review".


6 · Worked example: TIC 374861595

This section is an exhibit, not a result. No planet is claimed.

6.1 What the survey found

A blind search recovered a 1.937-day, ~8.4 % (trapezoid) signal on TIC 374861595 independently in sectors 30, 31 and 35, with depths consistent sector to sector (8.39 / 8.35 / 8.51 % ± 0.07) and odd/even eclipse depths equal at 0.26 σ, 0.59 σ and 1.66 σ per sector, stacking to 2.4 σ over 1,088 in-transit points. The host is a mid-M dwarf at 222 pc: T_eff 3445 ± 157 K, R★ 0.616 ± 0.019 R☉, Tmag 14.08 (TIC v8). The disposition is lead-awaiting-human-review, the terminal machine state, and it is where the object has stayed.

6.2 What SPOC saw first

SPOC detected this signal as TCE 1 and has redetected it in every 2-minute sector the target has been observed in. Its multi-sector Data Validation fit (product label s1-s96, spoc-5.0.125) reports 259 observed transits against 980 expected, MES 508.6, model SNR 507.4, bootstrap false-alarm probability 0, suspectedEclipsingBinary: false, an odd/even statistic of 1.288, and a difference-image centroid 0.60″ ± 2.50″ from the catalogue position across 23 sectors with all 23 quality metrics good.

The coverage is 2020 onward, not 2018. The DV product's own sectorsObserved bitmap marks 23 sectors and none of them early: the first falls in the high 20s and the last in the mid 90s, and the run described in §7 found light curves for this target beginning at sector 27 — mid-2020, two years after TESS began. The span between the first and last cadence of the multi-sector fit is 1,365,963 two-minute cadences, 1,897 days ≈ 5.2 years. An earlier revision of this section said "every 2-minute sector since 2018" and "seven years"; both were wrong, and both are retracted in Appendix B.

One detail is deliberately left imprecise here. Read one-indexed, the bitmap names sectors 28–97; read zero-indexed it names 27–96, which is the reading that agrees with the product's own s1-s96 label and with the sector-27 start the §7 run observed. The two readings differ by one sector number and agree on everything the argument uses — 23 sectors, first in 2020, a 5.2-year baseline. The exact list is settled by the light-curve files the §7 run already holds and should be stated from those, not from this bitmap.

It was never promoted to TOI, in any sector, across that whole baseline.

The likeliest reading — stated as a reading and not as fact — is on the DV summary sheet itself, which prints R_p = 28.9 ± 5.2 R⊕ in red. A 10 % V-shaped transit on a Tmag 14 M dwarf implying a radius no planet has is the exact signature of a grazing eclipsing binary, and setting it aside is a defensible call on the information that sheet presents. We are not describing an error. We are describing the cost structure of triage at survey volume, in which high-significance but awkward signals — grazing, implausibly large, faint late-type host — are cheap to defer and expensive to resolve, and therefore accumulate.

6.3 The bound the promotion path does not draw

The discriminating test is the absent secondary eclipse, and the reason it works here is geometric.

At b = 0.90 the eclipse is grazing, and a grazing geometry is normally where photometric inference goes to die: the radius ratio k and the impact parameter b trade off so hard that neither is measured. But the same overlap area enters the primary and the secondary, so in the depth ratio the geometry cancels exactly and what remains is the surface-brightness ratio. The bound is therefore independent of b and k — independent, that is, of precisely the two quantities this fit cannot pin down.

Two independent routes give the same null: SPOC's weak-secondary search (max MES 3.3, 602 ± 168 ppm, at phase 0.328 d rather than 0.5 P) and this lab's undetrended per-event measurement (−159 ± 628 ppm over 34 events). The adopted 3 σ ceiling is 1,105 ppm.

Integrating Planck spectra over the TESS band against that ceiling (scripts/tic374861595_secondary_limit.py) excludes stellar companions by factors of 10–48, leaves early-L marginal, and puts the cut-off at T ≲ 1,800 K. Both stated caveats travel with the number: reflected light is ignored, which makes the bound conservative, and a blackbody overestimates cool-dwarf flux, which makes the true cut-off looser than quoted.

An earlier revision of the package claimed exclusion "by two orders of magnitude". That was wrong, is retracted in the package, and is not recovered here.

The measurement itself is not new. SPOC's Data Validation, inherited from Kepler's, already turns the weak-secondary depth into planet effective-temperature and geometric-albedo comparison statistics (Twicken et al. 2018, PASP 130, 064502). What this section adds is narrower: a band-integrated exclusion of stellar companions, and the observation that the geometry cancels in the depth ratio. It holds only if the signal is on this star. Under a blend, the eclipsing pair's primary is not this M dwarf and the conversion no longer applies — the case the ρ★ tension in §6.4 leaves open.

Conclusion: a stellar companion is excluded. A giant planet and a cool brown dwarf are not distinguished, and no photometry can distinguish them. Only radial velocities separate them — K ≈ 300 m/s for 1 M_Jup against ≈ 15 km/s for 50 M_Jup at this period — and at Tmag 14.1 that is a 4-m-class spectrograph. This is the paper's one observational ask.

6.4 What is not measured

quantity state
radius bounded, not measured — and the refit widened the bound rather than closing it. A limb-darkened Mandel–Agol fit over 24 sectors (§7) returns k = 0.544 (+0.111 / −0.101) and b = 1.053 ± 0.134: the median geometry places the companion's centre outside the stellar disc, and roughly two-thirds of the marginal b posterior lies above b = 1. Across 1 σ in k, R_p spans 2.65 to 3.92 R_Jup, against SPOC's 2.59 ± 0.46. The k–b valley is the result here; a point estimate on it would be an artefact of where the sampler sat. Quote k with b or not at all. The joint posterior this row rests on is now serialisable — --chain writes the flat sample and the JSON carries a joint block with the covariance, the (k, b) correlation and a normalised 2-D density — but the 2026-09-18 run predates that flag, so the valley is asserted here from the marginals and the two-thirds figure rather than measured. One short re-run closes it; see §7.
R★ 0.6148 ± 0.0186 R☉, derived here (M_K = 4.982 ± 0.028) from the measured 2MASS Ks = 11.710 ± 0.026 — PSC 05542154−6407473, Qflg AAA, Cflg 000 — and the Gaia DR3 parallax 4.512610 ± 0.023275 mas (RUWE 1.05; TIC v8's 4.47187 is DR2). It reproduces TIC's 0.6159 to 0.2 %, which converts a copy into a check: TIC adopts Mann+2015 from M_K, so the agreement is expected, and the point is that the inputs are now measured rather than back-derived. Gaia GSP-Phot's 0.80 R☉ remains model-based and unreliable for M dwarfs, and is not adopted.
M★ 0.600 ± 0.013 M☉, settled 2026-09-18. Mann+2019 at this star's M_K, from coefficients now checked against the authors' own 400,000-sample MCMC posterior by scripts/mann_coefficients_check.py — a better reference than Table 6, which reports that posterior's medians. Those medians give 0.605; the 0.9 % difference from this repo's implementation sits inside the relation's own 1.3 % spread. The package's "Mann+2019 mass 0.72 M☉" is retracted: the relation reaches 0.72 only at M_K = 4.19, 0.79 mag brighter than this star — a different object, not a different rounding — and Mann+2015's own M_Ks→M★ row gives 0.637, so it is not that older relation misattributed either. No derivation for the 0.72 exists. What survives is a smaller real systematic worth carrying: Mann+2015's and Mann+2019's mass relations disagree by 6 % at this M_K, more than either one's quoted scatter. Mann+2019 is the one to use — dynamical masses, against Mann+2015's semi-empirical model-derived ones.
mass of the companion unknown, and no photometry can fix it.
ρ★ in tension, and the tension survived both a better fit and a derived radius. The transit shape gives 1.644 ρ☉ from SPOC's a/R★ and 1.685 ρ☉ (2.375 g/cm³) from the refit's own; the star gives 2.581 ρ☉ (3.640 g/cm³). Stated as the quantity the shape actually constrains: the star implies a/R★ = 8.971, the refit returns 7.781 ± 0.155 — a 7.7 σ disagreement. A 2026-09-18 revision briefly claimed the two agree to 11 % by converting one side to cgs and not the other; that claim is retracted and the tension is real. Three explanations remain, and the refit removed the easiest one: "R★ is smaller than TIC's" is now the weakest, because R★ is derived above from measured photometry and DR3 astrometry rather than copied. What is left is a non-circular orbit, a fit sitting on the wrong branch of the grazing valley, or an unresolved blend — the transit not being on the star these relations describe. This is a result to report, not a number to average away.
out-of-transit modulation 3.80–3.87 d at 0.6–1.6 % in three sectors, ≈ 2 P_orb. Probably host rotation near a 2:1 commensurability. Reported, not explained.
O−C drift Explained, and it is not a TTV. The guess above — trapezoid bias — was right in spirit and wrong in detail: the error is in the trapezoid's period, not in its mid-times. The trapezoid period sits 3.382 s per cycle short of SPOC's, 16 σ on its own quoted error, and a period error alone predicts −4.12 min of drift across 73 cycles against the −4.40 min observed. That is agreement to 7 %, from one number, with nothing fitted to it. No TTV is required and none is claimed; this is not the more interesting paper. Supporting: a single linear ephemeris fits all 289 transit windows over the 5.3-year baseline at χ²ᵥ = 0.919 on 105,227 points, so there is no large timing structure left to find. One residual is recorded rather than resolved: the refit's own period, 1.936952791 ± 1.1 × 10⁻⁷ d, differs from SPOC's 1.936948445 ± 2.1 × 10⁻⁷ by 0.376 s per cycle — formally 18 σ, across different sector coverage (the refit's 24 downloaded sectors against
SPOC's multi-sector product), and most likely systematic. SPOC's ephemeris is the one this paper quotes.

6.5 What the survey contributed, stated narrowly

Not the detection: SPOC's was first and better. Not the object's nature: that needs a spectrograph. What a blind search with a denominator adds is that this signal was recovered without prior knowledge inside a sample of known size with a full disposition record, so its survival means something quantifiable rather than meaning that somebody found it interesting. And the surface-brightness bound in §6.3 is a measurement that was available in the same public archive for the whole 5.2-year baseline, costs one pass over data already on disk, and is not drawn by the standard promotion path, which computes the same depth (§6.3) but does not turn it into this bound.


7 · What is blocked, and what it blocks

Nothing in this draft is now blocked on the archive. Three items were listed here on 2026-09-18; all three are recorded as resolved below rather than deleted, on the same principle as Appendix B: a blocker list that quietly loses entries cannot be audited.

Resolved 2026-10-08: the population estimate for the generalisation in §8. Listed here as "not in this repository and not attempted". It was pre-registered (docs/preregistrations/2026-10-08-paper-s8-class-census.md), counted by scripts/paper_s8_class_census.py over the public SPOC TCE and ExoFOP TOI tables, and is reported in §8 with its uncertainty. The archive itself was fetched on a machine with MAST access, as for the refit, and is pinned by SHA-256 in docs/survey/2026-10-08-s8-class-census.json rather than committed. It answered more than it was asked: the count is §8.2, and §8.3 found that the §6.3 test needs an odd/even gate before it can be run on a class at all.

Resolved: the limb-darkened refit and the Gaia-anchored R★. scripts/tic374861595_refit.py — a Mandel–Agol fit with Claret limb darkening returning (P, T₀, k, a/R★, b), plus the Mann relations so R★ is derived rather than copied — was run against MAST on 2026-09-18, on a machine with archive access; the environments the rest of this work was done in could not reach it. Output is committed at docs/submissions/TIC374861595-refit-2026-09-18.{json,log} and feeds §6.4's radius, R★, ρ★ and O−C rows. Four things about that run belong here rather than in the table:

Resolved: the Mann+2019 0.72 M☉ line. §6.4 had flagged it suspect because nobody in the loop had read Mann+2019 Table 6. That is now done, from a stronger source than the printed table — the authors' own 400,000-sample MCMC posterior, of which Table 6 reports the medians. scripts/mann_coefficients_check.py performs the comparison and is explicit about its three outcomes: agrees, disagrees, or could not be run. Findings: Mann+2015's three radius coefficients match the published table digit for digit; all six Mann+2019 mass coefficients sit within 1.31 σ of the authors' posterior median; the 7.5 zero point is confirmed against the authors' own mk_mass.py. The 0.72 is retracted (§6.4, Appendix B). One citation consequence: Mann+2015 Table 1 must be cited as corrected by the 2016 erratum, ApJ 819, 87 — the journal printed Tables 1–3 with press errors, and it is the erratum's values, not the original article's, that the relation here matches.

Two further things gate publication rather than the draft: a citable archived release of the now-public repository (§9; no DOI exists yet), and the standing project rule that papers are the last phase and nothing may describe a send that has not happened. No send has happened.


8 · The generalisable claim, and the size of the class it acts on

The survey-methods claim is that the disposition record and the refusals are the publishable content of a small archival search, and that both are nearly free. The vocabulary is one module. The placebo is the existing pipeline run on scrambled input. The per-host ladder is the existing search run on injected input. The refusal gate is the checker already required to grade a receipt. No part of this required new observations, new instruments or new statistics — it required deciding that the record was the product.

The astrophysical claim is narrower. The secondary-eclipse surface-brightness bound of §6.3 is cheap, needs no new observations, and is independent of the grazing degeneracy that makes this class of signal awkward to triage. The promotion path computes the same depth but does not draw this bound (§6.3). An earlier revision of this section said the class it would act on — high MES, high b, inferred R_p > 2 R_Jup, faint late-type host — was enumerable from the public DV catalogue, declined to enumerate it, and called the section a suggestion until someone did. This revision does, and the count changes what the section can say in both directions: the class is real and mostly unpromoted, and the test as §6.3 states it is not safe to run on it alone.

8.1 How the count was fixed

The cuts, the catalogue, the secondary-eclipse rule, the uncertainty treatment and what each outcome would mean were committed in docs/preregistrations/2026-10-08-paper-s8-class-census.md before any row of any TCE file was read. The count is made by scripts/paper_s8_class_census.py over the SPOC TCE statistics files from the MAST bulk-download page and the ExoFOP TOI and CTOI tables, all fetched 2026-10-08, with Tmag from TIC v8.2 for the 1,851 candidates the TCE files could not place; output, input SHA-256s and the Tmag table are committed under docs/survey/2026-10-08-s8-*.

Table 4 — class C. A TCE is in C if all five hold.

cut value
MES (tce_max_mult_ev) ≥ 50
impact parameter ≥ 0.7
R_p ≥ 2 R_Jup (22.42 R⊕)
host T_eff ≤ 4,000 K
Tmag ≥ 12.0

A star is promoted if it appears in the ExoFOP TOI table under any disposition, FP and FA included. For each unpromoted member, SPOC's own weak-secondary search supplies the ceiling: if its strongest event is below the 7.1 TCE threshold, the 3 σ ceiling on a secondary anywhere in the orbit is divided by the primary depth and converted to a companion temperature by the same band integration §6.3 uses, unchanged; a cut-off below 2,300 K counts as stellar companion excluded. Run on TIC 374861595's catalogue row, this reproduces §6.3 from the catalogue alone: 1,832 K, against the 1,825 K the DV-file numbers give and the ≲ 1,800 K §6.3 quotes.

8.2 The pre-registered count

The primary catalogue is SPOC's multi-sector product for sectors 1–96 — the one that holds TIC 374861595's fit — with 20,207 TCEs on 10,282 stars.

stars
in C 8 (9 TCEs)
promoted to TOI 2
never promoted 6 (one is a CTOI)
— significant secondary found by SPOC 3
— stellar companion excluded by the §6.3 bound 2
— not testable from the catalogue 1

The two exclusions are TIC 374861595 (cut-off 1,832 K) and TIC 29786532, a CTOI, at 2,268 K — 32 K inside the boundary, which is to say marginal and reported as marginal. The untestable member, TIC 307433122, has a positive weak-secondary MES and a negative fitted secondary depth, for which the pre-registered ceiling is undefined; it is counted as untestable rather than assigned a ceiling after the fact, and is recorded as the one place the pre-registration's text did not anticipate the data.

Uncertainty. The count is a census of a finite catalogue, so there is no sampling error. Perturbing R_p, b and T_eff by their catalogue errors over 2,000 draws gives a class of 8 (6–10) stars and 7 (5–8) unpromoted, median and 16th–84th percentiles. The definition matters far more than the measurements: across the pre-registered grid of 243 cut combinations the class runs from 1 to 35 stars and the unpromoted count from 1 to 30. One axis at a time from the primary cell, the unpromoted count moves 12 / 6 / 4 over MES 20 / 50 / 100, 6 / 6 / 4 over b 0.6 / 0.7 / 0.8, 7 / 6 / 5 over R_p 1.5 / 2.0 / 2.5 R_Jup, 6 / 6 / 9 over T_eff 3,900 / 4,000 / 4,500 K and 9 / 6 / 4 over Tmag 11 / 12 / 13. MES and brightness carry most of it.

By the outcome table fixed in advance, six unpromoted stars is a short follow-up list, not a population, and on this catalogue that is what §8 can claim.

8.3 The breadth check, and what it showed about the test

The multi-sector product is a narrow window. Of the 125 unpromoted class members found when every TCE product on the bulk-download page is read — 132 single- and multi-sector files, sectors 1–107, unioned by star — 114 have no TCE at all in the sectors 1–96 product. The breadth union, also pre-registered as a reported number, is:

stars
in C in any product 130
never promoted 125 (9 are CTOIs)

So the class is not a singleton. By this count roughly 96 % of SPOC 2-minute signals with this signature never reached the TOI list.

What follows was not pre-registered and is labelled exploratory wherever it is quoted. The same §6.3 rule, applied to each of the 125 on its highest-MES class TCE, returns:

verdict stars
significant secondary found by SPOC 43
stellar companion excluded by the bound 63
not excluded 18
not testable 1

Sixty-three looks like a result. It is mostly an artefact, and the reason is the most useful thing this section found. The surface-brightness bound is independent of the grazing degeneracy; it is not independent of the period. An equal-eclipse binary folded at half its true period puts its secondary exactly on top of its primary, where a weak-secondary search cannot see it, and the bound then "excludes" a stellar companion that is producing every eclipse in the light curve. The odd/even depth statistic exists to catch this configuration, and §6.1 checked it for TIC 374861595 before §6.3 was written. Read from the same TCE rows — reported, never used as a cut — 40 of the 63 have odd/even depths differing at more than 3 σ, three carry no odd/even statistic, and 20 pass: no significant secondary, no odd/even difference above 3 σ, and a stellar companion excluded by the bound. Four of the 20 are CTOIs; TIC 374861595 is one of the other sixteen.

Two further facts about the 20 belong beside the number. Eleven have periods under a day. And for five, the period is shorter than the Roche-limit period for a 13 M_Jup object at the catalogue radius (Rappaport et al. 2013), so the catalogue radius is not survivable for anything of planetary mass at that orbit: those five are a brown dwarf, a wrong radius, or a blend, and on none of those readings a planet. The catalogue R_p is a grazing fit, and §6.4 has already shown how far such a fit can move.

8.4 What the section now claims

  1. The class exists and is mostly unpromoted. Six stars on the pre-registered catalogue, 125 across every SPOC 2-minute product; a floor, because full-frame-image pipelines were not read.
  2. The test must be paired. As stated in §6.3 the bound is necessary and not sufficient. A pass that runs it without an odd/even gate would have reported 63 stellar exclusions where at most 20 survive. That is a correction to how this paper first framed the test, and it is recorded in Appendix B.
  3. Paired, it leaves 20 stars — exploratory, catalogue-level, with no new photometry — on which SPOC's own products already exclude a stellar companion and show no half-period alias. That is the list a radial-velocity follow-up would start from, and every member of it needs the per-event secondary measurement TIC 374861595 got (§6.3) before its catalogue ceiling is trusted.

None of the 20 is called a planet. An excluded stellar companion leaves a giant planet and a cool brown dwarf undistinguished, and the census counts objects on which one photometric test is decisive about one alternative. It does not count planets.


9 · Data and code availability

Every number in §§3–5 re-derives from the SHA-256-pinned receipts in reports/hunts/ by scripts/survey_paper_numbers.py, and tests/test_survey_paper_numbers.py checks this document's census table against that reader on every test run. Cached FITS bytes are pinned by SHA-256 in each receipt for spot reproduction within the checker's numerical tolerance; the fits are seed-pinned, not bit-for-bit across platforms.

The code and every committed receipt are public at https://github.com/benskamps/windowsill-lab, under the MIT licence; the repository was private when this section was first drafted on 2026-09-18 and was confirmed public on 2026-10-08. No archived release and no Zenodo DOI exist yet, so the repository's main branch is the only published copy and it can change under a reader. A citable snapshot is planned before submission, and until it is, this sentence is the statement Rule 5 of the project's publication contract requires. The code is not "available on request": it is available.

The 531 MB of SPOC TCE catalogues behind §8 are not in the repository. They are public at MAST and pinned by SHA-256 in docs/survey/2026-10-08-s8-class-census.json, so a reader fetches the same bytes rather than trusting ours.


Appendix A · Where each number comes from

paper number derived by from
census, Table 1 scripts/survey_paper_numbers.py::census reports/hunts/*.json rows
disposition counts, Table 2 same, star-level ledger, newest verdict wins same
recoveries, Table 3 same, known_planet rows excluding TFOPWG FP/FA same
refusals, §3.3 lab.publish._accepted_hunt_receipts → lab.checks.a05_control_verdict same
lead rulings, §5 lab.publish._shelf_states → docs/shelf-rulings.json ruling file + receipts
vocabulary size lab.a05_vocab.MACHINE_DISPOSITIONS source
threshold, pooled null, §2.3 receipt pooled_null blocks 5 receipts
candidate parameters, §6 docs/submissions/TIC374861595-CTOI.md §1 SPOC DV XML, committed
secondary-eclipse bound, §6.3 scripts/tic374861595_secondary_limit.py SPOC DV + lab per-event fit
class census, §8 scripts/paper_s8_class_census.py MAST TCE statistics + ExoFOP TOI/CTOI, SHA-256 in docs/survey/2026-10-08-s8-class-census.json
class cuts and outcome rule, §8 docs/preregistrations/2026-10-08-paper-s8-class-census.md committed before the catalogue was read

Appendix B · Corrections carried forward

Eight claims made during preparation were withdrawn and are recorded rather than overwritten, because a package that hides its retractions is not one a referee should trust:

withdrawn claim status
"stellar and L-type companions excluded by two orders of magnitude" overstated; correct answer is 10–48× for stars, early-L marginal, cut-off T ≲ 1,800 K
"the fit and catalogue densities agree to 11 %" wrong; caused by converting one side to cgs and not the other. The factor-1.56 tension is real
"12,898 targets searched" a count of target-searches, not of stars; §3.1
"the refit covered sectors 27–97" a range nobody can re-derive: the 2026-09-18 receipts record no sector list, and the two readings of the DV bitmap disagree about the top end. What is supported is 24 sectors beginning at sector 27. Corrected 2026-09-19; §6.4, §7
"SPOC has redetected it in every 2-minute sector since 2018" / "never promoted to TOI in seven years" wrong on both counts. The DV product's own sectorsObserved bitmap marks 23 sectors, none early; the §7 run found light curves beginning at sector 27. Coverage starts in 2020 and spans 1,897 days ≈ 5.2 years. Retracted 2026-09-19 against the committed DV XML; §1, §6.2, §6.5
"Mann+2019 mass 0.72 M☉" wrong, and no derivation for it ever existed. Mann+2019 gives 0.605 M☉ at this star's M_K and reaches 0.72 only at M_K = 4.19, 0.79 mag brighter. Retracted 2026-09-18 against the authors' own posterior; §6.4, §7
"independent of the grazing degeneracy … applying the test to that class is one pass over data already on disk" (§8, 2026-09-18) half right. It is independent of the grazing (k, b) degeneracy and blind to a half-period alias, where an equal-eclipse binary's secondary is folded onto its primary. Run unpaired over the class it reported 63 stellar exclusions, 40 of them on odd/even differences above 3 σ. The test must be paired with odd/even. Corrected 2026-10-08; §8.3
"one measurement the standard promotion path does not make" (abstract, §1, §6.3, §6.5, §8) overstated. SPOC/Kepler DV already converts the weak-secondary depth into planet-temperature and albedo statistics (Twicken et al. 2018). The new part is the band-integrated stellar exclusion and the geometry cancelling in the ratio, conditional on the signal being on the target. Corrected 2026-10-09; §6.3