Broken Branch · Labs · a research wing

As Seen on TV

Claims from TV and YouTube, taken seriously enough to measure. Each episode gets a real simulator, a check written down before the run that is allowed to fail, and a one-line verdict.

Episode list rendered from the lab’s registry · the registry as JSON · coming soon

Verdict in

Tested

23 episodes have been run against a preregistered gate and judged. They sit in 5 halls, grouped by the kind of claim.

Hall 1 of 5

One spiral, many bodies

Spirals turn up in shells, ears, antennas and brass. These episodes ask what a coil really does to a wave.

Wave energy in the coiled duct at k = 2, 6.3 and 20, driven from the wide end (top) and from the tight end (bottom). At k = 2 the wave fills the whole coil; at 6.3 it dies out by the last turn; at 20 it is gone within the first turn.
The cochlea
The sixth note of four tubes of the same length: straight, one gentle U-bend, one tight U-bend and four bends. The pressure pattern runs through the bends almost as if they were not there; only in the tightest bend does it lean across the tube.
Coiled brass
Probe temperature across the disk at k = 30 with one 45-degree slice of the surroundings hot. Empty disk: at most 0.343. Circle with a gap: at most 0.751. Golden spiral: at most 0.876, highest in its chamber. Nowhere reaches 1.
Does the mirror 'focus' anything?
Tested · verdict in

HI-9 · Coiled brass

Level 2 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. Why coiling a tuba barely moves its notes, unless the bends are tight.

The question. Does coiling a tuba change its sound?

Nothing there In a 2-D model, coiling a tube gently, with bends at least three tube widths in radius, moves none of its first eight notes by more than 4.3 cents, below what an ear can pick out; tight bends do push notes sharp, by up to 18 cents for one U-bend and 24 cents for four moderate bends.

Tested · verdict in

HI-1 · The twist that wasn't

Level 3 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. How a spiral twists the waves that leave it, and how a software bug once faked a bigger result.

The question. Does a Kozyrev mirror do anything?

Real effect, different reason A spiral does twist the waves that escape it, by ordinary reflection. In equilibrium the twist is zero, and the old +19.05 was an integrator artifact. The mechanism is textbook prior art.

Tested · verdict in

HI-12 · Does the mirror 'focus' anything?

Level 3 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. Why a spiral mirror brightens some spots but cannot heat anything above its surroundings.

The question. The episode's actual claim: a spiral concentrates an ambient energy.

Real effect, different reason In a 2-D wave model the spiral raises ambient wave energy in spots, by up to about 1.5x at the frequencies sampled, as any reflector does. A probe at the same temperature draws no net power from it, and in this model no passive probe ends up hotter than its hottest source.

Tested · verdict in

HI-2 · The sound windmill

Level 3 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. When sound can turn a spiral like a windmill, and why something always has to power it.

The question. Can a Kozyrev mirror be a motor as a rotor?

Real effect, different reason In the 2-D model a Kozyrev spiral turns when something powers it: a speaker inside pushes it by recoil, and a sound beam it partly absorbs can drag it round on a nearly frictionless mount. A lossless spiral in a steady plane wave settles at one angle, uniform noise does nothing, and whether the 3-D build turns is untested.

Tested · verdict in

HI-5 · The cochlea

Level 3 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. What the coil in your inner ear does to sound waves, and what it does not do.

The question. Does the coil help us hear bass?

Real effect, different reason In a 2-D toy duct coiled like a cochlea, the coil does push wave energy toward the outer wall, by 1 to 5 %, but more for high pitches than low ones, so in this toy the push is real and the bass advantage is not; the toy has no membrane, and the published model's effect lives in the membrane's short, slow waves.

Tested · verdict in

HI-4 · The wound-up antenna

Level 4 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. Why a log spiral sends sound out in a steady beam over four octaves, though not the way antenna theory predicts.

The question. Is a log spiral really scale-free?

Real effect, different reason In a 2-D wave model a log spiral does send sound out in a steady beam across more than four octaves, steadier than a spiral of constant width, but not by turning with frequency as the antenna principle predicts: the sound winds out along the arm and leaves through its mouth, and the end of the arm aims it.

Tested · verdict in

HI-7 · Drone-ID by spinning noise

Level 4 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. Whether a ring of microphones can count a drone's blades and tell which way it spins.

The question. Can a mic ring read a rotor's blade count and spin direction?

Nothing there In a 2-D wave model a ring of 12 microphones does not reliably read a rotor's blade count: 16 of 20 near the centre against a bar of 18, every miss beside a reflecting wall, and 4 of 20 farther out; the spin direction held up much better, right for 36 of 40, though that was counted after the run.

Tested · verdict in

HI-8 · The twist sorter

Level 4 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. Whether twisted sound can sort left-handed shapes from right-handed ones.

The question. Can twisted sound separate left- from right-handed objects?

Real effect, different reason In a 2-D wave model twisted sound does push a three-armed pinwheel and its mirror image apart, by about 6 % of the force on them, but a plain wave pushes them apart nearly three times harder per unit of sound energy, so the shape's handedness, not the beam's twist, does the sorting.

Hall 2 of 5

Echoes, rumbles and hums

Rooms, stones, shells and a whole Moon, struck or hummed and then listened to.

Plan view of a 30 by 10 foot room at its 18.7 Hz mode. Top: pressure swing, bright at both end walls and dark at the desk halfway down. Bottom: air motion, brightest at the desk and dark at both ends.
The fear frequency
Left: waves from 19 sources on a curved arc converging on a grey slab. Right: a decibel ladder with 127 dB at the slab at the bottom, 150 dB jet engine, 160 dB lab levitator, 184 dB needed to lift the slab, and 191 dB where the air's troughs reach vacuum.
Acoustic levitation of stone
Loudness at the seismometer against time for four bodies. The solid, hollow and plain solid Moons all fade slowly at about the same rate; the Earth-like one drops away within one crossing time.
The ringing Moon
Tested · verdict in

HI-19 · Acoustic levitation of stone

Level 1 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. How hard sound can really push, and why drums and horns cannot lift a stone slab.

The question. Could nineteen drums and horns lift a stone slab by sound?

Nothing there Even granting nineteen instruments far louder than any real drum, all perfectly in step, with no losses over the 63 m and a free hundredfold boost, sound pushes on the slab with about 3 Pa. Lifting 0.5 m of rock takes 13,000 Pa, 4,100 times more. The levitator physics the episode cites is real, but it holds millimetre beads at around 160 dB; it does not scale to a stone. Whether the 1939 event happened cannot be tested.

Tested · verdict in

HI-6 · The seashell

Level 1 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. Why a seashell seems to hold the sea, and why it cannot make the room any louder overall.

The question. Does a shell 'amplify' the sea?

Nothing there In a 2-D wave model, a shell reshapes the room's noise at the ear, up to about 1.9 times louder in some bands and a third quieter in others, but adds no energy: an ear at room temperature draws no net power from it, and a silent room stays silent. The preregistered check that the pitch follows the shell's size failed too, because its peak rule found no peak; a later overlay, not preregistered, finds that it does.

Tested · verdict in

HI-18 · The fear frequency

Level 2 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. How a room can hum at 19 Hz, and why the desk sat where the air moves most, not where the pressure swings.

The question. Could a fan in Vic Tandy's lab set up a 19 Hz standing wave where he saw his 'ghost'?

Real effect, different reason Tandy's 30 ft lab, closed at both ends, does ring at about 19 Hz (18.8 Hz in theory, 18.7 in the wave model). But the spot halfway down the room, where his foil blade shook hardest and where he sat, is where the air moves most and the pressure swings least, under 1 % of its value at the end walls. The standing wave is real; the desk sat on its motion peak, not its pressure peak. Separately, 7 Hz lies outside the alpha band (8–12 Hz), and neither figure appears in Tandy's paper.

Tested · verdict in

HI-20 · The ringing Moon

Level 2 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. Why the Moon can ring like a bell for an hour without being hollow.

The question. Does a Moon that 'rings like a bell' for an hour need to be hollow?

Real effect, different reason The ringing is real, and a solid Moon does it too. Struck once in a 2-D wave model, a solid Moon with a rubbly crust rings for 13.7 crossing times, 87 % as long as a hollow shell (15.6); a plain solid one rings 15.7. Give the same Moon Earth-like loss and the ringing is gone in under one crossing. How long a body rings is set by how little energy it loses, and the dry Moon loses very little. Its moment of inertia, 0.393, also rules out a thin shell (0.667).

Hall 3 of 5

Lucky guess or real signal?

Claims that stand or fall on a count. Each one is checked against the odds of a lucky guess.

Tested · verdict in

HI-10l · The balance bracelet

Level 1 of 5statistics

You’ll learn. Why people balance better on the second try, with the band or without it.

The question. Does the in-store balance demo measure the wristband, or the second try?

Real effect, different reason In the published crossover data the second try beats the first on every test whichever band is worn, while the band itself makes no detectable difference, so a demo that always tests without the band first shows 62 to 72 % of people “improving” with it. Three preregistered checks missed because the assumed test-retest correlation was too low; this verdict rests on an addendum declared after the first run.

Tested · verdict in

HI-10g · The Munich dowsers

Level 2 of 5statistics

You’ll learn. Why the best of many lucky guessers always looks impressive.

The question. Do the best dowsers in the Munich pipe trials beat what picking the best of many chance guessers gives?

Nothing there Picking the best of 104 chance test series gives a run as good as the Munich best about one time in five (21.7 % of 20,000 simulated worlds), and chance alone gives seven series below 5 % about one time in four, so the reported best dowsers are what best-of-many chance looks like. Six planted skilled dowsers stand out at P = 0.0002, so the test can say yes.

Tested · verdict in

HI-10m · Water crystals

Level 3 of 5statistics

You’ll learn. Why counting the bottles, not the judges, changes the answer in the water-crystal studies.

The question. Does the water-crystal result hold when water samples, not judges, are the units?

Nothing there The water was treated bottle by bottle, with two treated bottles in each study, and counted that way no test can reach a P below 1 in 6 (2006) or 1 in 15 (2008), whatever the judges saw. In simulated worlds with no effect at all, counting each judge's rating as independent comes out “significant” about four times in ten.

Coming to this hall, 4 episodes not yet run:

Hall 4 of 5

Something for nothing

Gadgets that promise more than physics pays for: fuel from water, extra heat, a sticker that blocks a phone, motors that run on magnets alone.

Tested · verdict in

HI-10i · The water car

Level 1 of 5per claim

You’ll learn. Why splitting water and burning the gas never gives back more energy than the split cost.

The question. Can splitting water and burning the gas return more energy than the split cost?

Nothing there In a step-by-step simulation, a parked car whose engine only ran the electrolyser made 0.13 mol of new gas for every mole it burned, and with every step loss-free the loop returns exactly what the split cost, never more. On the road, fuelled only by gas from water, the car stopped for good 0.8 km into ten drive cycles, once its starting battery ran down.

Tested · verdict in

HI-10h · The phone radiation sticker

Level 1 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. Why a sticker over the earpiece barely changes the radiation that reaches your head.

The question. How much does a small metal patch over a phone's earpiece cut the field at the head?

Nothing there In a 2-D wave simulation, a 1.5 cm metal patch over the earpiece cuts the power absorbed in the head by about 0.3 dB, or 7 %, at 900 and 1800 MHz, not 97 to 99 %, because the energy comes from the antenna. A closed metal ring around the antenna cuts it by about 50 dB, so the simulation can see a real block.

Tested · verdict in

HI-10k · The hot tube

Level 3 of 5per claim

You’ll learn. How one number about a hot surface's glow shrinks a claimed 3x heat output to about 1.2x.

The question. Does the E-Cat's reported excess heat survive the right emissivity for its surface?

Nothing there Re-read with the emissivity alumina has in the camera's own band, the report's temperatures give about 1.2 times the electrical input, not 3.1 to 3.7, short of the 1.5 the claim needed to survive. The friendliest reading, calibrating the camera on the report's own dummy run, gives 1.7: still half the claim, and on an emissivity the one measured spectrum contradicts.

Coming to this hall, 7 episodes not yet run:

Hall 5 of 5

At the edge of physics

Time run backward, an atom held still by looking, gravity that pushes, a hidden fifth dimension, and stars measured where they used to be.

Tested · verdict in

HI-15 · Star 'torsion' at true positions

Level 3 of 5history

You’ll learn. How to check old star sightings against modern positions, and why they matched the old maths instead of the sky.

The question. Did Kozyrev detect stars at their calculated present and future positions?

Nothing there The published star detections agree with the parallaxes of their day, including ones since revised by 2-5 sigma, and miss the modern positions by 13-27 arcsec. The agreement is with the calculation, not with the sky.

Tested · verdict in

HI-11 · Time reflection, the real 'bending time'

Level 4 of 52-D wave simulator

You’ll learn. What time reflection really is: a signal reversed and retuned by switching a material, with no time travel.

The question. The episode cites the 2023 CUNY time-reflection experiment. What does it actually show?

Real effect, different reason Time reflection is real and matches the textbook formulas to within 0.25 %: a medium switched uniformly in time reverses a signal's order and shifts its frequency, with the switch supplying the energy. Nothing reaches a time before its cause, so it is not bending time or time travel.

Tested · verdict in

HI-24 · The watched atom

Level 5 of 5per claim

You’ll learn. How watching a qubit on a real IBM chip freezes it, and what each look costs.

The question. Does watching a quantum system really stop it from changing, and what does each look cost?

The claim holds Checking a qubit over and over does freeze it: on a real IBM quantum chip, a qubit watched 16 times on its way to flipping stayed put 76.7 % of the time, against 0.5 % unwatched. Every look leaks about 0.7 % of runs, so the freeze tops out near 77 %, and the “watcher” is a physical measurement, not a pair of eyes.

Tested · verdict in

HI-10d · Repulsive gravity, by post-selection

Level 5 of 5per claim

You’ll learn. How gravity can push a probe away in a rare sorted subset of runs while the average still pulls.

The question. Can gravity push a probe away, and if so, only in which sense?

Real effect, different reason In a step-by-step quantum simulation, gravity from a mass in superposition pushes the probe away in the rare sorted subset, as the paper says, while the average over all runs stays the ordinary pull. The preregistered check that the push is the weak value missed narrowly: 2.13 % off at the sharpest sorting angle, against a 2 % bar. It is a conditional shift of an average, not a force anyone can use.

Tested · verdict in

HI-16 · The fifth dimension

Level 5 of 5per claim

You’ll learn. How electromagnetism falls out of a tiny fifth dimension, and why the simplest version is not our world.

The question. Is electromagnetism really the shadow of a fifth dimension?

The claim holds Electromagnetism is exactly the geometry of a small fifth circle: charge is how many times a wave winds round it, and a gauge change is a relabelling of the circle. The simplest version is not our world: its charged particles are about 10²¹ too heavy for their charge, it cannot make left-right asymmetric matter, and its own vacuum energy pulls the circle shut.

Coming to this hall, 3 episodes not yet run:

Not yet tested

Coming soon

14 episodes are planned, and the ones with a hall are listed under it above. Nothing in this section is a result, and each gate is a draft until its preregistration is committed. The coming-soon page has every one in full.

Also on the coming-soon page: 25 ideas on the shelf, and 5 claims from the shows that no instrument can reach.

The rules

Three kinds of verdict

Every verdict is one of three kinds. There is no fourth. A claim that points at nothing measurable gets named, not judged.

The claim holds

The effect is there, and for the reason given.

Real effect, different reason

Something real is going on, but the explanation attached to it is wrong.

Nothing there

The effect does not show up once the instrument can be trusted.

How an episode moves: queued→preregistered→run→verdict→published

Fair to the people on screen. The shows and hosts cited here are real. We describe their claims neutrally, with the episode’s title, date and a link, and without their branding or transcript text. Verdicts are about claims, never about people. When a claim points at something real, the verdict says so.

The episode registry, the preregistrations and the results live in the lab’s notebook, which is not public yet. This page is rendered from a copy of the registry, so it can only show a result the notebook already holds. Back to the lab →